How to Choose Advertising for Your Site, Part 1: Quality Control

How to Choose Advertising for Your Site
In my last post, we covered whether or not we should even have advertising on our sites. And because I promised a follow-up post on how to go about selecting the right ads, here it is!

This is actually the first post in a series of seven, as the follow-up just got too damn long. For those of you who like advertising and enjoy my posts, that’s good news. If you hate my work, we’ll, you’re in for a long haul :) Let’s get to it:

There’s really not as much mystery surrounding the selection of proper advertising as there seems to be. I think it’s mostly common sense and you’ll recognize a lot of what we cover in this series, even if just in spirit.

The important thing to realize about choosing advertisements for your site is that it all comes down to one thing:

Money.

It’s money for you and it’s money for your advertiser, if you’re pushing new clients his way. If the ad you place on your site works well, your advertiser will keep purchasing ad space and you’ll both continue to both make money. If the ad doesn’t work it gets pulled and that’s bad for you.

Ads come in all shapes, sizes and colors. Sometimes all at once which is the unfortunate bit. But regardless of whether we’re talking header-wide banner ads or tidy little 125×125 ads (that’s pixel dimensions), there are some general guidelines you’ll want to follow. These guidelines will help you AND your advertisers get more bang for your buck and ensure the ad dollars keep rolling in.

Guidelines for selecting advertising for your site

1. Don’t reduce the quality of your site

This is a first on the list for good reason. Your site is your home. It’s your business. It’s a representation of your personality and professional appearance. In some cases it’s your livelihood. Don’t muck it up with ads that are hideous. Destroying a gorgeous site with some awkward ads for $40 a month is simply not worth it.

In this case “hideous” means:

  • Ultra flashy
  • Loud
  • Full of talking or sound effects
  • Unnecessarily sexual
  • Highly animated

A couple words about that list: talking ads and sound effects. First off, any site that has sound on it that automatically plays once the page loads should be burnt. Okay, so you can’t really burn a website, I know. It was just a suggestion. It’s alright to have sound on your site, but it shouldn’t play until your user clicks something and gives it permission.

Automatically playing sound is rude as hell. And it’s distracting. And it’s dumb. If I visit your site and some random voice starts yelling at me telling me I just won a new iPod, I’ll jump to crazy conclusions. The first being that you’re really hard up for some extra dough and probably aren’t very good at what you do. Not a fair assumption probably, but annoying sites do that to me.

Secondly, that’s just bad advertising. Ads like that don’t work, which means before long the ad will be pulled and you’ll lose ad dollars and possible affiliate income. Don’t do it.

As to the “unnecessarily sexual” point, that’s a judgment call, really. I can’t tell you what’s right for your site until I see it, but it’s a good bet that a lady with her boobies showing isn’t going to help you sell more product. Unless you’re selling bikinis. But not if you’re selling, say, lawn mowers. Unless they’re marital-aid lawn mowers. But I’m not really sure anyone has cracked that market yet. Just a thought.

This genius disguised by utter madness will continue in Part 2. You don’t want to miss it, so Subscribe Now!

Posted: Saturday, July 12th, 2008
Post by Charlie Pabst, creator of Ignite Living and Charfish Design. Have a big crush? You can read more about me here. And you can watch me abuse the Twittersphere here.

Like this post? Share it with your pals...

“I don’t need other newsletters. I read yours.”
– Kay

Subscribe

Make things people like. Market them wisely.
Be taken seriously. Collect dollars.


It’s free, safe, and you can bail at any time.

8 Responses to “How to Choose Advertising for Your Site, Part 1: Quality Control”

  1. Dave Navarro

    I agree. I don’t think a lot of people realize how your ads color your reputation – for good or for bad. Better to have no ads at all than one that makes you look desperate for business :-)

    Reply
  2. Charlie

    Dave -

    Indeed! I little money does a little bit of good. But a raunchy ad can do a LOT of harm.

    Thanks for the comment, dude!

    PS. Told you I’d post!

    Reply
  3. Kelly

    Charlie,

    Love your serious points. In fact, I just recovered from a computer crash caused by a site with automatically playing sound coming from a dude who followed me on the page (trying to find STOP) until I: closed the page. Crashed & restarted the computer. Found you waiting in my email inbox. Oh, thank goodness, a sane voice in the wilderness!

    Then you had to mention the marital mower. Bwah ha ha. You may have meant it in a raunchy way, but sorry, I’m having horror-movie visions instead. Could have improved my marriage greatly. Sort of. ;)

    Looking forward to pt.2.

    Regards,

    Kelly

    Reply
  4. Charlie

    Kelly -

    LOL! That’s actually similar to what prompted this series, in part. I was doing my ordinary surfing the webs thing while listening to earphones. I stumble upon a site that verbally insisted I’d just become an instant winner.

    Now, I don’t know how they did it, but the volume of the website ended up being way louder than the music I was listening to. It scared the bejeezus out of me and I said, “Why I ought to…” and other really dirty things.

    You should go back to that site and give the link to this post, and the series to follow…jerks.

    Oh and PS for anyone who’s getting ideas from the marital mower picture: Please don’t use an actual running lawn mower for anything other than cutting your grass.

    Reply
  5. Kelly

    Dave,

    Not nearly cold enough, I’m afraid. Thank goodness he’s one bad, bad penny among millions of fine specimens.

    Charlie,

    When you said “that’s what prompted this series” I’m thinking YOU were married to my ex, too? Who wasn’t he married to?

    Then I read further… “don’t use an actual running lawn mower…” darn. I was gonna pass the post on to his new wife.

    I heard she brought a mower to the marriage…

    I don’t think I can go back to that site without crashing the Mac again, so the other folks will just have to have my endless ire.

    There, I’m done. Not too good at endless ire.

    Endless marital mower jokes, on the other hand? That I can do.

    :)

    Later,

    Kelly

    Reply
  6. Amalia S.

    Hi! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this post to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!

    Reply
    • Charlie

      Thanks, Amalia! So glad you liked it.

      Certainly forward this to anyone you’d like. Would love to hear his thoughts as well :)

      Best!

      Charlie

      Reply

Leave a Reply